Video6:10
A paper estimating a wage drop for workers without a high-school degree
Source: Sample source · uploaded by sample_member
Credibility3.8(304)
Full context verifiedIssues › Immigration › Debates
ImmigrationLabor & wagesstarter
"Immigration lowers wages for low-income workers."
Neutral summary. Labor economists disagree about the size of any wage effect, and about whether it is concentrated among prior immigrants or among native-born workers without a college degree. This claim states the effect as a drop. The evidence is about the size and who bears it. Posted by sample_member · 9 days ago · 640 followers
Republican platform
Sample summary of a common Republican argument on this claim.
Sample summaryDemocratic platform
Sample summary of a common Democratic argument on this claim.
Sample summaryIndependents (survey)
Sample summary of where surveys usually split.
Sample summaryEvidence meter
Supports 52%Disputes 48%
Weighted by credibility and context ratings on this starter card. Not a verdict and not a live member poll.
8
Supporting items
Supporting items
8
Disputing items
Disputing items
3
Context flags
Context flags
1
Full versions linked
Full versions linked
Uploading evidence is coming soon. Commenting is below when accounts are open.
Supports the claim
Sample itemsVideo6:10
Local payroll panel before and after a large arrival year
Source: Sample source · uploaded by sample_member
Credibility3.2(256)
Context flag: clip is shorter than the sourceDisputes the claim
Sample itemsVideo6:10
A paper finding little effect once industry and age are held constant
Source: Sample source · uploaded by sample_member
Credibility4.1(328)
Full context verifiedVideo6:10
Metro-level wage growth in high-immigration cities
Source: Sample source · uploaded by sample_member
Credibility3.4(272)
Full context verifiedCivil discussion · 640
SR
sample_reader Independent · Center on this issue
Starter example · 6h ago
Before this leans either way, the two sources need the same years and the same geography. Right now they might be describing different places.
Logic 88Evidence 40Solution 22Reply
Member comments
These are saved to the account that wrote them. The notes above are starter examples.
Sign in to comment, vote, or report.